News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Mental health patients locked in police cells 

Mental health patients locked in police cells

31 Jul, 2010 09:59 AM
PATIENTS with serious mental health issues, some just teenagers, are being locked up in police cells awaiting expert assessment rather than risk theirs and others’ safety at Wodonga hospital.

A lack of suitable ­assessment areas and the risks posed in the emergency department have forced the measures.

The increasing burden of the mentally ill — health workers have seen more than 600 patients in the first six months of the year — has pushed the ­issue to breaking point.

Health experts say up to six people a month are now locked up while awaiting assessment.

Do you think the Border has a mental health problem? Let us know here

The Border Mail understands the issue was raised with the Victorian Department of Human Services more than a year ago and is still unresolved.

An ambulance officer said the cells provided the safest option but the fix was never intended to be permanent.

“Some mental health patients, in the acute stage of their illness, are so agitated and distressed their behaviour is a danger to themselves and others,” the paramedic said.

“They require specialist accommodation but it was realised that this cannot be provided in the emergency department as there are members of the public in all cubicles ... and ample medical equipment within grasping range of most beds can be used as weapons.

“In response, and with some trepidation, it was decided by all agencies involved in the care of mental health patients that the safest option was for police — who are often first line responders to them — to apprehend them and take them into the holding cells at the Wodonga station until mental health workers can attend ...”

Albury Wodonga Health head of adult mental health services at the Wodonga Campus Greg Calder says the emergency department needs to be redesigned to meet the specialist needs of the mentally ill.

“These people need privacy for themselves and others, somewhere that is safe for them, staff and patients,” he said.

The Police Association says the situation is the best result for police ­resources.

“The alternative is that Wodonga loses a van from the road as the officers babysit someone at the hospital,” union secretary Greg Davies said.

“The cells are the safest alternative and best way of keeping police on the road, responding to law and order issues.”

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Of course it does, the whole of Australia is backward when it comes to mental health.
Posted by Affirmative, 31/07/2010 10:06:20 AM, on The Border Mail
What ever happened to Mayday Hills??
Posted by reality, 31/07/2010 10:14:03 AM, on The Border Mail
Mayday Hills is now Latrobe University, Beechworth Campus. The use of large, enclosed institutions for those with mental illness has been deemed for some time to be inappropriate and unhelpful to patients seeking an independent life in the community. They are better served by short stay inpatient services such as the Kerford Unit at Wangaratta. Wodonga is the only regional city in Victoria without one.
Posted by philmart, 31/07/2010 10:43:26 AM, on The Border Mail
We all have issue, some more than others.
Posted by spicey, 31/07/2010 11:20:13 AM, on The Border Mail
Is the wording used by Greg Davis the Police union secretary a reflection of the attitude amongst police - the notion of having to "babysit" someone with a mental illness appears to be abhorrent to them. Better to lock them away than show compassion - Mental illness is a health issue not a corrections issue and people who are presenting with a mental health problems have a right to be treated with some dignity just like anyone else - which means not being "locked up" for being unwell! Oh and the comment about the cells being the best option so that police can be on the road responding to law and order issues - what a load of crock!!
Posted by Descriminatory, 31/07/2010 12:38:45 PM, on The Border Mail
The Police are frequently first responders, and as the sibling of someone with mental illness, I'm grateful for the extra training that they've been given over the years to recognise people who may be going through a mental-health crisis, and how to handle and treat them in the short-term. I think that an individual, safe jail cell can be appropriate on the very-short term (seen by a medical professional within an hour or so) if a safe medical facility isn't available, but we need to improve resources to treat the patients on the longer term, and to help their families understand what the patient is going through and the best way to help them.
Posted by been there, 31/07/2010 3:10:16 PM, on The Border Mail
Of course the border ahd Mental Health issues, so does all of Australia, we need to work Nationally to sort through this issue and help lessen the burden. A forum to identify issues not just professionals, client participation as well, get the real insight. Go to the people in need.
Posted by Di, 31/07/2010 5:08:54 PM, on The Border Mail
The Border, as with the rest of Australia, does have major Mental Health problems that have been ignored for decades. Why? Because it is a SAFE seat for the politicians so nothing happens here, unless very strong & brave individuals stand up and push for a cause. We all need to create a massive stir, Wodonga & Albury, we must be united. The river between us in not the Berlin Wall but it might as well be for all the little help we get from successive governments.
Posted by listen, 31/07/2010 6:44:01 PM, on The Border Mail
I am a general nurse who works in a small hospital in NSW and our workload is becoming more about helping those with mental health issues. This poses a challenge as it is something that my colleagues and I are not trained for but we do the best we can. We rely heavily on the mental health teams from Albury and Wagga but they are very busy and their resources are stretched with their own local issues and they work very hard to assist us and our patients. They do an exceptional job but their limits are stretched. Unfortunately most patients experience their crisis after hours when resources are even more limited. Services in our area need to be increased not decreased. Ambulance, Police and health workers are the frontline in treating and caring for these people with minimal training and knowledge sometimes at great risk to themselves. We need to know that that there is professional advisors available 24/7 to give our patients the best posible care. I will not start on the facilities availble to us or the ability to provide a safe environment that can prevent self harm. Supervision is a problem as our staffing does not allow for close observation without negleting our other patients
Posted by rexyroses, 31/07/2010 7:52:36 PM, on The Border Mail
The Liberal Party cut doctors training when they came to power, they did not have any idea that it takes 12 years of training to become a psychiatrist. It was only in the dying days of the Howard Government that Doctor numbers were dramatically increased. I hope we burn this into the minds of our local members at the next election. This is not acceptable, we have a need for good mental health services, and the community expects better. We have a model of containment in police cells as we simply do not have enough staff. Greg Calder does a fantastic job but he struggles with resources from the new Albury Wodonga Health. The hospital merger has been terrible for Mental Health services. The Wodonga Staff are now run by an executive of people who ran Southern Health.
Posted by Dave, 1/08/2010 10:59:21 AM, on The Border Mail
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

Most popular articles

RPI Production
1) Apple iPhone 4 32GB44 plans 12%
2) Apple iPhone 4 16GB44 plans 14%
3) Motorola Quench7 plans 3%
4) HTC Desire4 plans 1%
5) Apple iPhone 3GS 8GB33 plans 2%

Mobile Phones | Broadband Plans

Get the best deal at Fairfax Digital - Rural Press

 
 
Advertising Promotion


The Border Mail







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Navigate

Classifieds

More Ways to Read

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2010. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...