So who’s a racist? Not you, of course. Certainly not me. Hey, maybe none of us.
No, that’s not what people were saying this week as the sports commentator Warren Ryan quit his job over an on-air quote from Gone with the Wind that included the word “darky”.
Here was another controversy, depressingly fresh on the heels of last year’s furore over indigenous AFL player Adam Goodes being called an ape by a young spectator.
It may pay to look at the bigger picture. After all, aren’t we living in an era when evil is an outmoded concept, when there are no bad people, only bad acts? On that basis it seems counterintuitive and frankly crazy to label people racist on the basis on one or two remarks.
Yes, of course, “the standard I walk past is the standard I accept”, to quote another example of vogue reasoning. Sorry but I have walked past it plenty.
I walked past it when a man in Spain told me he was “working like a black”, when an old girlfriend asked whether I still “smoke like a Turk” and when a fella in country NSW offered me his ultimate accolade: “Thanks mate, you’re a white man.”
Hey, I also walked past it when people assert that Australia is a uniquely wicked racist country.
Yes, Australian country towns once banned Aborigines from swimming pools. From this came the “freedom rides” led by Charlie Perkins. And the treatment of indigenous Australians by white settlers and government authorities remains unfinished business.
But how many people alive today are honest to God racist?
You know, willing to stand at the school gates like a southern US governor in the 1950s and ’60s and say non-white children will not pass?
Refuse to shake the hand of a non-white person? Oddly, when Iran’s President Hassan Rouhani failed to offer his hand to European Union High Representative Catherine Ashton, there was not a glimmer of protest.
Are white South African migrants to Australia racist? Are black Zimbabwean leaders racist for pushing whites off farms? Considering the hierarchy of oppression that is so fashionable now, are any non-white people racist at all?
Certainly it is much easier, then, to turn on some middle-aged white bloke for saying something, well, stupid.
For seemingly endless days in May, CNN’s television coverage was obsessed with the Donald Sterling controversy. The billionaire owner of the US basketball team the Los Angeles Clippers was rightly denounced in all quarters for moronic comments about black people.
He now has to sell the franchise and will end his days as a pariah.
Isn’t that enough? Not for CNN, though that network was not alone. Its anchors weighed every nuance, parsing comments by his wife that Sterling had dementia, interviewing each other endlessly.
For what? Only because there are dollars at stake did Sterling even matter. Otherwise that old man’s thoughts are irrelevant to everyone but him and the nurse with the bedpan.
I’d rather ask how healthy it is for any sporting team to be owned by a single plutocrat?
My contention is that people can say racist things because they are afflicted, temporarily or permanently, with stupidity, but that doesn’t make them a racist.
Why? Because I don’t believe there are that many true racists. These would be people obsessed with the supremacy of their race to the exclusion of any other topic.
I’d wager that the overwhelming majority of us, no matter the colour, are roughly as “racist” as each other.
In other words, not really racist at all. It’s just that we sometimes say stupid things.